How Remarriage Affects Alimony in Illinois

How Remarriage Affects Alimony in Illinois: A Comprehensive Legal Guide

Few questions create more anxiety during and after an Illinois divorce than those surrounding spousal maintenance—commonly known as alimony. When you've structured your post-divorce financial life around either receiving or paying maintenance, the prospect of remarriage (whether your own or your former spouse's) can throw everything into uncertainty. Will the payments stop? Can they be modified? What legal steps must be taken to protect your interests?

The intersection of remarriage and alimony in Illinois involves complex statutory provisions, evolving case law, and significant financial stakes. Whether you're a maintenance recipient considering walking down the aisle again, a payor hoping for relief from your obligations, or someone simply planning for their financial future, understanding how Illinois law treats this issue is essential.

This comprehensive guide examines every aspect of how remarriage affects alimony in Illinois, including the automatic termination provisions under state law, the differences between various types of maintenance, the impact of cohabitation versus legal marriage, and the practical steps you should take to protect your rights. We'll also explore how Cook County and Chicago courts typically handle these matters and provide real-world examples to illustrate key concepts.

Understanding Spousal Maintenance Under Illinois Law

Before diving into how remarriage affects alimony obligations, it's crucial to understand the foundational framework of spousal maintenance in Illinois. The Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act (IMDMA), codified at 750 ILCS 5/504, governs all aspects of maintenance, including its award, duration, modification, and termination.

Types of Maintenance in Illinois

Illinois recognizes several distinct categories of spousal maintenance, each with different characteristics that affect how remarriage impacts the obligation:

• Temporary Maintenance: Awarded during the pendency of divorce proceedings to maintain the status quo until a final judgment is entered. This type of maintenance is governed by 750 ILCS 5/501(a)(1).
• Fixed-Term Maintenance: Awarded for a specific period, often calculated using statutory guidelines based on the length of the marriage. Under 750 ILCS 5/504(b-1), the duration is determined by multiplying the length of the marriage by a specific factor.
• Reviewable Maintenance: Set for a specific term but subject to court review at the end of that period to determine whether it should continue, be modified, or terminate.
• Indefinite Maintenance: Awarded without a specific end date, typically in long-term marriages (generally 20 years or more) or when circumstances make it appropriate.
• Permanent Maintenance: While less common after recent statutory amendments, permanent maintenance may still be awarded in exceptional circumstances and cannot be modified except under specific conditions.

The Statutory Framework: 750 ILCS 5/510

The modification and termination of maintenance are governed primarily by 750 ILCS 5/510. This statute establishes the rules for when maintenance obligations can be changed or ended, including specific provisions regarding the recipient's remarriage. Understanding this statute is fundamental to grasping how remarriage affects your maintenance rights or obligations.

Section 510(c) specifically addresses the termination of maintenance, stating: "Unless otherwise agreed by the parties in a written separation agreement set forth in the judgment or otherwise approved by the court, the obligation to pay future maintenance is terminated upon the death of either party, or the remarriage of the party receiving maintenance..."

Automatic Termination Upon Remarriage: The General Rule

The default rule in Illinois is clear and straightforward: when the maintenance recipient remarries, the payor's obligation to continue making maintenance payments automatically terminates. This principle is codified in 750 ILCS 5/510(c) and represents the legislature's recognition that the recipient's new spouse assumes primary financial responsibility for their support.

How Automatic Termination Works

Under Illinois law, the termination of maintenance upon remarriage is self-executing. This means:

• The obligation ends as of the date of the recipient's remarriage
• No court order is required for the termination to take effect
• The payor is not required to continue payments after the remarriage date
• Any payments made after the remarriage date may potentially be recovered as overpayments

However, while the termination is automatic as a matter of law, prudent practice dictates that the payor should take affirmative steps to document the termination and protect against future disputes. This typically involves filing a motion to terminate maintenance and obtaining a court order confirming that the obligation has ended.

The Rationale Behind Automatic Termination

The automatic termination rule reflects several policy considerations that Illinois courts have consistently recognized:

Prevention of Double Support: When a maintenance recipient remarries, they gain access to the financial resources and support obligations of their new spouse. Allowing maintenance to continue would essentially require the first spouse to subsidize the second marriage.

Clean Break Philosophy: Illinois divorce law increasingly embraces the concept that former spouses should eventually achieve financial independence from one another. Remarriage represents a significant step toward that independence and a new chapter that should not be encumbered by obligations from the prior marriage.

Encouraging Self-Sufficiency: The termination rule incentivizes maintenance recipients to develop their own earning capacity and make independent financial decisions rather than remaining dependent on their former spouse indefinitely.

The Critical Exception: Written Agreements to the Contrary

While automatic termination upon remarriage is the default, Illinois law explicitly allows parties to contract around this rule. Section 750 ILCS 5/510(c) begins with the crucial language "Unless otherwise agreed by the parties in a written separation agreement set forth in the judgment or otherwise approved by the court..."

Non-Modifiable Maintenance Agreements

Sophisticated divorce negotiations often result in agreements that modify or eliminate the automatic termination provision. Parties may agree that maintenance will:

• Continue for a specified period regardless of remarriage
• Continue indefinitely regardless of remarriage
• Reduce (but not terminate) upon remarriage
• Terminate upon remarriage but with a lump-sum payment due
• Be completely non-modifiable for any reason, including remarriage

These provisions are particularly common in cases involving high-net-worth individuals, long marriages, or situations where the maintenance recipient sacrificed significant career opportunities during the marriage.

Requirements for Valid Non-Termination Agreements

For an agreement to effectively override the automatic termination rule, Illinois courts require:

• Written Form: The agreement must be in writing. Oral agreements to continue maintenance after remarriage are generally unenforceable.
• Clear Language: The intent to override the termination provision must be expressed clearly. Ambiguous language will typically be construed in favor of termination.
• Court Approval: The agreement must either be incorporated into the dissolution judgment or separately approved by the court.
• Voluntary Execution: Both parties must have entered into the agreement voluntarily, with full knowledge of its implications.

Case Law: Interpreting Non-Termination Provisions

Illinois courts have addressed the interpretation of non-termination provisions in numerous cases. In In re Marriage of Blum, 91 Ill. 2d 226 (1982), the Illinois Supreme Court emphasized that when parties agree to non-modifiable maintenance, courts must enforce that agreement according to its terms, even if circumstances change dramatically.

More recently, in In re Marriage of Dynako, 2014 IL App (2d) 121224, the Appellate Court examined whether language in a marital settlement agreement effectively waived the termination-upon-remarriage provision. The court held that waiver of the statutory termination rule requires clear and explicit language; merely stating that maintenance is "non-modifiable" does not necessarily prevent termination upon remarriage unless the agreement specifically addresses remarriage.

This distinction is critical: an agreement stating that maintenance cannot be modified regarding amount or duration may still allow for automatic termination upon remarriage unless remarriage is specifically addressed.

Cohabitation: The Middle Ground

While remarriage triggers automatic termination of maintenance, cohabitation presents a more nuanced situation under Illinois law. The statutory framework treats cohabitation as grounds for termination but requires a court proceeding and specific findings rather than automatic termination.

The Cohabitation Provision: 750 ILCS 5/510(c)

The same statutory section that addresses remarriage also provides for termination based on cohabitation: "...or upon the maintenance recipient cohabiting with another person on a resident, continuing conjugal basis, the obligation to pay future maintenance is terminated."

However, unlike remarriage, cohabitation does not automatically terminate the obligation. The payor must file a motion and prove that the cohabitation exists on a "resident, continuing conjugal basis."

Defining "Resident, Continuing Conjugal Basis"

Illinois courts have developed a body of case law interpreting this standard. Key factors courts consider include:

• Shared Residence: Whether the parties live together in the same dwelling as their primary residence
• Duration and Continuity: Whether the living arrangement is ongoing rather than temporary or sporadic
• Economic Interdependence: Whether the parties share expenses, bank accounts, or other financial resources
• Social Presentation: Whether the parties hold themselves out as a couple to friends, family, and the community
• Intimate Relationship: Whether the relationship has a romantic or sexual component

The seminal case of In re Marriage of Herrin, 262 Ill. App. 3d 573 (5th Dist. 1994), established that courts must look at the totality of the circumstances rather than any single factor. Occasional overnight stays or dating relationships typically do not meet the statutory threshold.

Why Some Recipients Choose Cohabitation Over Remarriage

Given the automatic termination rule for remarriage, some maintenance recipients make a calculated decision to cohabit rather than marry. This strategy carries risks and limitations:

• The payor can file a motion to terminate based on cohabitation, though they bear the burden of proof
• Investigating and proving cohabitation can be time-consuming and expensive
• The cohabiting recipient forfeits the legal protections of marriage
• If the relationship ends, the recipient has no spousal support rights from the new partner

Courts have shown some frustration with recipients who appear to be deliberately avoiding marriage to preserve maintenance. In In re Marriage of Snow, 322 Ill. App. 3d 953 (2d Dist. 2001), the court noted that the cohabitation provision was enacted precisely to address situations where recipients were essentially married in all but name.

The Payor's Remarriage: A Different Analysis

A frequently misunderstood aspect of Illinois maintenance law concerns the payor's remarriage. Unlike the recipient's remarriage, the payor's decision to remarry does not automatically terminate or modify the maintenance obligation.

No Automatic Termination for Payor Remarriage

Illinois law is clear: the maintenance payor's remarriage, standing alone, does not affect their obligation to continue making payments. The statutory termination provisions in 750 ILCS 5/510(c) specifically reference "remarriage of the party receiving maintenance"—not the party paying maintenance.

This means that if you are paying maintenance and decide to remarry, you:

• Must continue making maintenance payments as ordered
• Cannot use your new spouse's income as a reason to reduce payments
• Cannot claim that your new financial obligations justify modification
• May face additional financial strain from supporting two households

Can the Payor Seek Modification Based on Changed Circumstances?

While remarriage itself is not grounds for modification, 750 ILCS 5/510(a-5) does allow for modification of maintenance based on a "substantial change in circumstances." However, courts have consistently held that voluntary lifestyle changes—including remarriage—do not constitute the type of substantial change that warrants modification.

In In re Marriage of Shen, 2015 IL App (1st) 130733, decided by the First District Appellate Court (which includes Cook County and Chicago), the court emphasized that a payor cannot create their own hardship through voluntary choices and then seek modification based on that hardship. Taking on new financial obligations through remarriage falls squarely within this principle.

Impact of New Spouse's Income

An important nuance involves whether a new spouse's income can be considered in maintenance proceedings. Illinois courts have generally held:

• A new spouse's income cannot be directly factored into maintenance calculations
• However, courts may consider how shared living expenses affect available resources
• A new spouse's contribution to household expenses may increase the payor's ability to meet maintenance obligations
• Courts retain discretion to examine the overall financial picture

Practical Scenarios: How Remarriage Affects Alimony in Different Situations

Understanding how these rules apply in practice requires examining specific scenarios that commonly arise in Illinois divorce cases.

Scenario 1: Standard Fixed-Term Maintenance

Facts: John and Mary divorced after 15 years of marriage. John was ordered to pay Mary $3,000 per month in maintenance for 8.4 years (the statutory guideline duration). Three years into the maintenance term, Mary remarries.

Result: Mary's maintenance terminates automatically upon her remarriage. John's obligation to pay $3,000 per month ends as of Mary's wedding date. John should promptly file a motion to formally terminate maintenance and stop making payments. If John continues paying after the remarriage (perhaps unaware of it), he may be entitled to recover those overpayments.

Scenario 2: Non-Modifiable Maintenance Agreement

Facts: In their divorce, Susan and Robert agreed that Robert would pay Susan $5,000 per month in "non-modifiable maintenance" for 10 years. The agreement does not specifically address remarriage. Four years later, Susan remarries.

Result: This scenario requires careful analysis of the agreement language. Under In re Marriage of Dynako, simply calling maintenance "non-modifiable" may not prevent termination upon remarriage. Unless the agreement specifically states that maintenance will continue regardless of remarriage, Susan's remarriage likely triggers automatic termination. However, Robert should consult with an attorney and may need court interpretation of the agreement.

Scenario 3: Explicit Continuation Despite Remarriage

Facts: David and Jennifer divorced after 25 years of marriage. Their marital settlement agreement states: "David shall pay Jennifer maintenance of $6,000 per month for her lifetime, and this obligation shall not terminate upon Jennifer's remarriage." Five years later, Jennifer remarries.

Result: Because the agreement explicitly addresses remarriage and states that the obligation continues despite remarriage, David must continue paying. The clear contractual language overrides the default statutory termination rule.

Scenario 4: Cohabitation Suspected

Facts: Michael pays his former wife Linda $4,000 per month in maintenance. Michael learns that Linda has been living with her boyfriend for over a year. They share expenses, present themselves as a couple, and the boyfriend has moved all his belongings into Linda's home.

Result: Michael may file a motion to terminate maintenance based on cohabitation. He must prove that Linda is cohabiting "on a resident, continuing conjugal basis." Given the facts described, Michael likely has a strong case, but he bears the burden of proof and should gather evidence such as financial records, utility bills, mail delivery information, and testimony from neighbors or mutual acquaintances.

Scenario 5: Payor Remarries

Facts: Karen pays her former husband Bill $2,500 per month in maintenance. Karen remarries a man with significant income and reduces her work hours to spend more time with her new spouse.

Result: Karen's maintenance obligation continues unchanged. Her remarriage does not affect Bill's right to receive maintenance. Furthermore, Karen's voluntary decision to reduce her work hours is unlikely to constitute grounds for modification. Karen is expected to continue meeting her maintenance obligations regardless of changes in her personal life.

Cook County and Chicago-Specific Considerations

For those navigating maintenance and remarriage issues in the Chicago metropolitan area, understanding local court procedures and practices is essential.

Filing in Cook County Domestic Relations Division

The Domestic Relations Division of the Circuit Court of Cook County handles all family law matters, including maintenance modification and termination proceedings. Key practical considerations include:

• Venue: Post-decree motions to modify or terminate maintenance must generally be filed in the court that entered the original divorce decree
• Case Management: Cook County uses an electronic case management system; parties should ensure all filings are properly uploaded and served
• Local Rules: Cook County Circuit Court Rules supplement the Illinois Supreme Court Rules and may impose additional requirements for motion practice
• Courtroom Procedures: Each judge may have individual practices regarding motion calls, evidence presentation, and briefing schedules

Discovery in Cohabitation Cases

When seeking to terminate maintenance based on cohabitation, the payor must gather sufficient evidence. In Cook County, discovery tools commonly used include:

• Subpoenas for financial records, utility bills, and lease agreements
• Interrogatories regarding living arrangements and financial sharing
• Requests to admit specific facts about the cohabiting relationship
• Depositions of the maintenance recipient and potentially the alleged cohabitant

Private Investigation Considerations

Many payors hire private investigators to document cohabitation. While this is permissible, there are important limitations:

• Investigators must operate within legal bounds—no trespassing, wiretapping, or harassment
• Evidence obtained illegally may be inadmissible and could expose the payor to liability
• Surveillance should be conducted from public areas
• Documentation should include dates, times, photographs, and detailed observations

Procedural Steps: What to Do When Remarriage Occurs

Whether you're the maintenance recipient who has remarried or the payor seeking termination, specific procedural steps should be followed.

For the Maintenance Payor

If you learn that your former spouse has remarried:

1. Verify the Remarriage: Obtain a copy of the marriage certificate or other reliable documentation of the remarriage date
2. Review Your Divorce Judgment: Carefully examine the maintenance provisions to determine whether any non-termination language exists
3. Cease Payments: Once remarriage is confirmed and you've verified no contrary agreement exists, you may stop making maintenance payments as of the remarriage date
4. File a Motion: File a motion to terminate maintenance with the court that entered your divorce decree, even though termination is automatic
5. Seek Recovery of Overpayments: If you made payments after the remarriage date, your motion should include a request to recover those amounts
6. Update Withholding Orders: If maintenance was being withheld from your wages, ensure the income withholding order is terminated

For the Maintenance Recipient

If you are receiving maintenance and plan to remarry:

1. Review Your Agreement: Before remarrying, review your divorce judgment and marital settlement agreement to understand the implications
2. Financial Planning: Develop a financial plan that accounts for the loss of maintenance income
3. Notification: While not always legally required, providing notice to your former spouse of your remarriage avoids complications and potential recovery of overpayments
4. Consider Timing: If you are close to the end of your maintenance term, you may want to consider the financial implications of remarrying before versus after the term ends

Modification Versus Termination: Understanding the Distinction

Illinois law draws an important distinction between modification and termination of maintenance, and the rules differ significantly.

When Modification is Appropriate

Under 750 ILCS 5/510(a-5), maintenance may be modified upon a showing of a "substantial change in circumstances." Factors courts consider include:

• Changes in either party's employment status or income
• Changes in either party's needs
• Disability or serious illness
• Retirement
• Changes in the cost of living
• Property transfers or other financial changes not contemplated in the original order

Modification changes the amount or duration of maintenance but does not end the obligation entirely.

When Termination Occurs

Termination completely ends the maintenance obligation. Under Illinois law, termination occurs:

• Automatically upon death of either party
• Automatically upon remarriage of the recipient (absent contrary agreement)
• Upon court order finding cohabitation on a resident, continuing conjugal basis
• At the end of a fixed-term maintenance period
• Upon court order following review of reviewable maintenance

The "Permanent" Termination Principle

An important principle in Illinois law is that once maintenance is terminated, it cannot be reinstated. This means:

• If maintenance terminates due to the recipient's remarriage, it cannot be revived even if that new marriage ends in divorce or annulment
• If maintenance terminates due to cohabitation, it cannot be reinstated if the cohabitation ends
• Once a fixed term ends, the recipient cannot seek an extension (though reviewable maintenance may be extended upon proper showing)

This principle was reinforced in In re Marriage of Walters, 238 Ill. App. 3d 1086 (1st Dist. 1992), where the court held that maintenance terminated by operation of law upon remarriage cannot be revived, even when the second marriage is annulled.

Special Considerations for High-Asset Divorces

In high-net-worth divorces common in Chicago's affluent suburbs and downtown areas, maintenance issues often involve additional complexities.

Complex Property Division Affecting Maintenance

In cases involving substantial assets, maintenance is often interrelated with property division. Courts and parties may structure settlements where:

• A lower maintenance amount is exchanged for greater property division
• Maintenance is secured by specific assets or trusts
• Maintenance is tied to business performance or investment returns
• Life insurance policies are required to secure the maintenance obligation

When remarriage occurs in these cases, unwinding the interconnected arrangements can be complex and requires careful legal analysis.

Trust-Based Maintenance Structures

Some high-asset divorces use trusts to fund maintenance obligations. These structures may:

• Provide for continued distributions regardless of remarriage
• Specify termination events that may or may not align with statutory provisions
• Create enforcement mechanisms separate from court processes
• Generate tax consequences that must be considered in planning

If your divorce involved trust-based maintenance, the trust document's terms—not merely the statutory defaults—will govern how remarriage affects your rights.

Tax Implications of Maintenance Termination

The tax treatment of maintenance changed significantly with the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, affecting divorces finalized after December 31, 2018.

Post-2018 Divorce Tax Rules

For divorces finalized after 2018:

• Maintenance payments are not tax-deductible for the payor
• Maintenance payments are not taxable income for the recipient
• Termination of maintenance does not have direct tax consequences

Pre-2019 Divorce Tax Rules

For divorces finalized before 2019 (unless modified after):

• Maintenance payments are generally tax-deductible for the payor
• Maintenance payments are taxable income for the recipient
• Termination upon remarriage eliminates both the deduction and the income inclusion

Planning Considerations

For recipients under pre-2019 agreements, remarriage eliminates taxable income from maintenance. However, this may be offset by the complete loss of those funds. Recipients should work with financial advisors to understand the net impact of remarriage on their overall financial situation.

Common Questions About Remarriage and Alimony in Illinois

What if I don't know my former spouse remarried?

The automatic termination provision operates regardless of whether the payor has knowledge of the remarriage. If you continued making payments after your former spouse remarried, you may be entitled to recover those overpayments, typically through a motion in the original divorce case. Courts generally hold that the recipient has an obligation to notify the payor of the remarriage.

Does a destination wedding or foreign marriage count?

Yes, if the marriage is legally valid where performed and would be recognized under Illinois law, it triggers the automatic termination provision. Illinois generally recognizes marriages validly performed in other states and foreign countries.

What about same-sex marriages?

Following Obergefell v. Hodges, 576 U.S. 644 (2015), same-sex marriages are recognized throughout the United States. A recipient's same-sex marriage terminates maintenance just as a heterosexual marriage would.

Can we agree to terminate maintenance before remarriage?

Yes, parties can negotiate a lump-sum buyout of maintenance or agree to terminate the obligation in exchange for other consideration. Such agreements must be approved by the court to be enforceable and should be documented in writing.

What if my former spouse is planning to remarry—can I stop payments early?

No. An engagement, wedding planning, or even a scheduled wedding date does not terminate maintenance. The obligation continues until the actual remarriage occurs. Stopping payments prematurely exposes the payor to enforcement actions, including contempt of court.

Key Takeaways

• Automatic Termination is the Default: Under 750 ILCS 5/510(c), maintenance automatically terminates when the recipient remarries, unless the parties agreed otherwise in writing.
• Agreements Can Override the Default: Parties can contractually agree that maintenance will continue despite remarriage, but such agreements must be in writing, clearly address remarriage, and be approved by the court.
• Cohabitation Requires Court Action: Unlike remarriage, cohabitation does not automatically terminate maintenance. The payor must prove cohabitation "on a resident, continuing conjugal basis" through a court motion.
• Payor's Remarriage Doesn't Affect Obligation: If the maintenance payor remarries, their obligation continues unchanged. The statutory termination provision only applies to the recipient's remarriage.
• Review Your Agreement Carefully: Before making any decisions about remarriage, carefully review your divorce judgment and marital settlement agreement with an experienced attorney.
• Take Formal Steps: Even when termination is automatic, file appropriate motions to formally terminate the maintenance order and address any overpayments.
• Plan Financially: Recipients should develop a comprehensive financial plan before remarrying, accounting for the complete loss of maintenance income.
• Termination is Generally Permanent: Once maintenance terminates (whether by remarriage, cohabitation, or expiration of the term), it typically cannot be reinstated, even if circumstances change.

Protecting Your Interests: The Importance of Experienced Legal Counsel

The intersection of remarriage and alimony in Illinois involves high financial stakes, complex statutory provisions, and nuanced case law. Whether you are a maintenance recipient considering remarriage, a payor seeking termination of your obligation, or someone currently negotiating a divorce agreement, the decisions you make can have lasting financial consequences.

Attempting to navigate these issues without experienced legal guidance can lead to costly mistakes. Recipients may inadvertently forfeit substantial maintenance rights, while payors may continue making payments they are no longer obligated to make. In high-asset cases, the amounts at stake can be substantial—sometimes millions of dollars over the life of a maintenance obligation.

Contact Beermann LLP for Experienced Illinois Family Law Representation

At Beermann LLP, our Chicago family law attorneys have decades of experience handling complex maintenance issues, including those involving remarriage, cohabitation, and non-modifiable agreements. We represent clients throughout Cook County and the greater Chicago metropolitan area in all aspects of divorce and post-decree proceedings.

Our attorneys understand the nuances of Illinois maintenance law and stay current on the latest statutory changes and appellate decisions. We can help you:

• Negotiate maintenance provisions that protect your interests regardless of future remarriage
• Evaluate existing agreements to determine how remarriage will affect your rights
• File and prosecute motions to terminate maintenance based on remarriage or cohabitation
• Defend against improper attempts to terminate maintenance
• Develop comprehensive financial plans that account for maintenance termination
• Handle appeals in disputed maintenance cases

Don't leave your financial future to chance. Whether you're paying maintenance and believe your obligation should end, or you're receiving maintenance and want to understand your rights before making life decisions, the experienced attorneys at Beermann LLP can provide the guidance you need.

Contact Beermann LLP today to schedule a consultation with one of our experienced Illinois family law attorneys. We serve clients throughout Chicago, Cook County, and the surrounding communities, providing sophisticated legal representation in even the most complex maintenance disputes.

Need Cybersecurity Help? Jonathan D. Steele also provides cybersecurity consulting through Steele Fortress for clients concerned about digital security during divorce.

Written by Jonathan D. Steele

Chicago divorce attorney with cybersecurity certifications (Security+, CEH, ISC2). Illinois Super Lawyers Rising Star 2016-2025.

Free Consultation

For more insights, read our Divorce Decoded blog.