Is there an advantage to filing for divorce first in Illinois?

Yes, there are several strategic advantages when you file for divorce first in Illinois. The petitioner (person who files first) gets to present their case first at trial, set the initial tone of the proceedings, and has more time to prepare financially and emotionally. Additionally, filing first allows you to choose the timing and potentially the venue of your case under 750 ILCS 5/104, which can be particularly important if you or your spouse might relocate. However, these advantages are procedural rather than substantive—Illinois courts are required to treat both parties fairly regardless of who initiated the divorce.

What happens legally when I file for divorce first in Illinois?

When you file for divorce first in Illinois, you become the 'Petitioner' and your spouse becomes the 'Respondent,' and automatic Temporary Restraining Orders typically go into effect preventing both parties from dissipating assets or hiding money. Your spouse will be served with the petition and summons, and they have 30 days to file their response under Illinois Supreme Court Rules. Filing first also triggers your ability to request temporary orders for support, custody, and exclusive possession of the marital home under 750 ILCS 5/501. The court will then schedule initial hearings, and you'll maintain control over moving the case forward.

Does filing for divorce first mean I get to keep the house in Illinois?

No, filing for divorce first in Illinois does not automatically entitle you to the marital home. Under 750 ILCS 5/503, Illinois courts divide marital property based on equitable distribution factors, not on who filed first. However, if you file first, you can simultaneously petition for exclusive possession of the marital residence under 750 ILCS 5/501(c-2), which may give you a temporary advantage while the divorce is pending. The court will consider factors like which parent has primary custody of children, each spouse's financial situation, and whether domestic violence is a concern when making this determination.

Can the person who files for divorce first pick the judge in Illinois?

No, you cannot directly choose your judge when you file for divorce first in Illinois—cases are typically assigned randomly through the court's case management system to ensure fairness. However, filing first does allow you to select which county to file in if multiple venues are legally appropriate under 750 ILCS 5/104, and different counties may have judges with varying reputations or approaches to family law matters. Some experienced divorce attorneys in Illinois strategically time filings based on judicial rotation schedules, though this practice has limited predictability. The bottom line is that while filing first gives you some control over venue, judge selection remains largely outside your direct control.

Does filing for divorce first affect child custody decisions in Illinois?

Filing for divorce first in Illinois does not directly influence how a judge will allocate parental responsibilities (custody) under 750 ILCS 5/602.5 and 602.7, as courts must base these decisions solely on the best interests of the child. However, there are indirect strategic advantages: filing first allows you to immediately request a temporary parenting schedule that may establish a status quo the court is reluctant to disrupt later. Additionally, being the petitioner means you present your custody case first at trial, which can help frame the narrative around parenting. The parent who files first also has more time to document their involvement in the children's lives and consult with custody experts if needed.

What is the strategic advantage of being the petitioner in an Illinois divorce?

Being the petitioner when you file for divorce first in Illinois provides several strategic advantages beyond just procedural benefits. You control the timeline, allowing you to prepare your financial documentation, secure legal representation, and emotionally ready yourself before your spouse knows divorce is imminent. At trial, the petitioner presents their case first and also gets the final word in rebuttal, which can be psychologically impactful on the judge. You can also include specific requests in your initial petition—such as maintenance, property distribution preferences, or parenting arrangements—that set the framework for negotiations. Perhaps most importantly, filing first prevents your spouse from filing in a different, potentially less favorable jurisdiction if relocation is a possibility.

Should I wait for my spouse to file for divorce first in Illinois?

Waiting for your spouse to file for divorce first in Illinois is generally not recommended if you've already decided the marriage is over, as you lose important strategic advantages and control over the process. By waiting, you may be caught off-guard, have less time to prepare financially, and potentially face a filing in an inconvenient venue if your spouse relocates. However, there are limited circumstances where waiting might make sense—such as if you're trying to reach the 10-year marriage mark for Social Security benefit purposes, or if you're gathering evidence of hidden assets. If you're considering divorce, consulting with an Illinois family law attorney before your spouse files can help you understand whether to file for divorce first in Illinois or strategically wait based on your specific circumstances.

Does filing for divorce first affect property division in Illinois?

Filing for divorce first does not give you a legal advantage in property division under Illinois law, as 750 ILCS 5/503 requires courts to divide marital property equitably based on specific statutory factors regardless of who initiated the case. However, filing first provides practical advantages: you can ensure automatic restraining orders protect marital assets immediately, you have more time to inventory and value assets before your spouse can hide or dissipate them, and you can request temporary exclusive possession of certain property. The petitioner also presents their property division case first at trial, allowing them to frame the narrative around what constitutes a fair distribution. Strategic preparation before filing—including documenting assets, obtaining valuations, and understanding your spouse's financial situation—often matters more than simply being first to file.

How long do I have to respond if my spouse files for divorce first in Illinois?

If your spouse files for divorce first in Illinois, you have 30 days from the date you are properly served to file your Response (also called an Appearance and Answer) with the court under Illinois Supreme Court Rules. Failing to respond within this timeframe can result in a default judgment, meaning the court may grant your spouse everything requested in their petition without your input. If you need additional time, you can file a motion requesting an extension, which courts typically grant for good cause. It's crucial to contact an Illinois divorce attorney immediately upon being served—even if you ultimately agree to the divorce—to protect your rights regarding property division, maintenance, and parental responsibilities under 750 ILCS 5/503, 504, and 602.

Can filing for divorce first affect temporary support orders in Illinois?

Yes, when you file for divorce first in Illinois, you gain the ability to immediately request temporary maintenance (spousal support) and child support orders under 750 ILCS 5/501, potentially securing financial support faster than if you waited. The petitioner can include these requests in their initial filing and schedule an emergency hearing if circumstances warrant, while a respondent must wait to be served and then file their own motion. Courts calculate temporary child support using Illinois's income shares model under 750 ILCS 5/505, and temporary maintenance using the statutory formula in 750 ILCS 5/504—these calculations don't favor either party based on who filed. However, the strategic advantage of filing first lies in timing: you can secure support orders while your spouse is still organizing their response, providing crucial financial stability during the divorce process.

Should You File for Divorce First in Illinois? Strategic Advantages

The question lands in my inbox at least twice a week: "My marriage is over. Should I race to the courthouse before my spouse does?" It's a reasonable question—and the internet is filled with oversimplified advice suggesting that filing first gives you some magical advantage in Illinois divorce proceedings.

Here's the reality I share with clients at Beermann LLP after handling hundreds of Cook County divorces: filing first provides tactical advantages, not legal ones. Illinois courts don't award bonus points to whoever submits paperwork first. But timing your filing strategically? That can position you favorably for negotiations, temporary orders, and the overall trajectory of your case.

Let me break down exactly when filing first matters, when it doesn't, and how to make this decision based on your specific circumstances rather than internet myths.

The Legal Reality: Illinois Courts Don't Favor the Petitioner

Before diving into strategy, let's establish what Illinois law actually says. Under the Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act (750 ILCS 5/), there is no statutory advantage given to the person who files for divorce first (the "petitioner") versus the person who responds (the "respondent").

The court's role is to divide marital property equitably under 750 ILCS 5/503, determine parenting arrangements in the children's best interests under 750 ILCS 5/602.5, and award maintenance based on statutory factors under 750 ILCS 5/504. None of these statutes include "who filed first" as a relevant consideration.

What "Equitable" Actually Means

Illinois is an equitable distribution state, not a community property state. This means judges divide assets based on what's fair—considering factors like each spouse's contribution to marital property, duration of marriage, and each party's economic circumstances—not automatically 50/50. Filing first doesn't shift this analysis one inch in your favor.

The Automatic Restraining Order Applies to Both Parties

Once a divorce petition is filed in Illinois, automatic restraining orders under 750 ILCS 5/501(a-1) immediately prohibit both parties from dissipating assets, hiding money, or making major financial moves without court approval or written consent. These restrictions apply equally whether you're petitioner or respondent.

Key Takeaway: Don't file first expecting legal favoritism. File first when tactical advantages align with your specific situation and goals.

Seven Strategic Advantages of Filing for Divorce First

While the law doesn't favor petitioners, real-world divorce proceedings involve strategy, timing, and psychological dynamics that can be influenced by who initiates. Here's where filing first genuinely helps:

1. Control Over Timing and Preparation

The petitioner chooses when the divorce begins. This means you can:

Complete your divorce preparation checklist without time pressure
Gather financial documents while you still have access to marital accounts
Secure copies of tax returns, investment statements, and business records
Interview and retain the best divorce attorneys before your spouse does
Arrange living situations and support systems

When your spouse files first, you're immediately reactive. You have 30 days to respond under Illinois Supreme Court Rules, and you're scrambling to find an attorney while simultaneously processing the emotional shock of being served.

2. Venue Selection in Multi-County Situations

The petitioner files in their county of residence (or the county where the respondent resides). If you and your spouse live in different counties—say, you've already separated and moved to DuPage while your spouse remains in Cook—you can choose which county hears your case.

This matters more than most people realize. Different counties have different:

Court cultures and judicial temperaments
Case backlogs affecting how quickly you reach trial
Local rules about discovery timelines and motion practice

3. Presenting Your Case First at Trial

If your divorce proceeds to trial (which only about 5% of Illinois divorces do), the petitioner presents their case-in-chief first. You set the narrative. You establish the framework through which the judge first views the disputed issues.

Psychologically, going first allows you to frame contested issues on your terms. Your spouse then responds to your framing rather than establishing their own.

4. Access to Emergency Relief

When you file for divorce, you can simultaneously file emergency motions for:

Exclusive possession of the marital home (750 ILCS 5/701)
Temporary child support and maintenance
Restraining orders beyond the automatic ones
Orders protecting children from removal from Illinois

If you're in a situation involving domestic violence, dissipation of assets, or concern about parental kidnapping, filing first with emergency motions can provide immediate protection.

5. Financial Documentation Before Dissipation

The moment divorce papers are served, sophisticated spouses (and their attorneys) start thinking about asset protection—sometimes crossing into improper dissipation. By filing first, you trigger the automatic restraining orders before your spouse has time to move money, change beneficiaries, or "gift" assets to family members.

Pro Tip: In my cybersecurity work, I've seen spouses attempt to hide cryptocurrency or move assets through complex digital transactions after receiving divorce papers. Filing first—and immediately issuing preservation letters to financial institutions—can prevent costly forensic accounting battles later.

6. Psychological Positioning

Being the petitioner subtly positions you as the actor rather than reactor. In negotiations and mediation, this framing can matter. You're the one who made a decision and took action. Your spouse is responding to your initiative.

This psychological dynamic doesn't influence judges (they see through it), but it can affect how settlement negotiations unfold between parties and their attorneys.

7. Control Over Service Timing

Once you file, you control when your spouse is served. Under Illinois law, you have 30 days from filing to complete service. This gives you flexibility to:

Wait until after a major family event
Ensure you're physically separated before service
Coordinate with your attorney's schedule for emergency hearings
Avoid serving during your children's school events

Key Takeaway: The biggest advantage of filing first is preparation time and control over logistics—not any legal preference in how your case is decided.

When Filing First Can Backfire

Need Help With Your Illinois Divorce?

Every case is unique. Get personalized guidance from an experienced Illinois family law attorney.
Schedule Free Consultation
Or call: (312) 555-1234

Strategy isn't one-size-fits-all. In some situations, being the respondent is actually preferable:

Financial Discovery Advantages for Respondents

Here's something most attorneys won't tell you: respondents sometimes gain intelligence advantages. When you're served with a divorce petition, you can immediately observe how your spouse characterized assets, debts, and grounds for divorce. You learn their strategy before revealing yours.

If your spouse files a poorly prepared petition or makes admissions in their initial disclosures, you can use that information strategically.

The "Bad Guy" Perception

In some marriages—particularly where reconciliation might be possible or where children are old enough to understand what's happening—being the one who "filed" carries emotional weight. If preserving family relationships matters to you, sometimes letting your spouse initiate reduces conflict.

I've seen high-conflict divorces where the filing party was portrayed as abandoning the family, regardless of underlying facts. This perception doesn't affect legal outcomes, but it can affect family dynamics for years.

When You're Not Yet Ready

Filing before you're prepared is worse than responding after you're served. If you haven't:

Gathered essential financial documents
Secured independent legal counsel
Established a separate bank account for living expenses
Made arrangements for housing
Protected your digital accounts and passwords

Then racing to file first puts you in a worse position than waiting.

Warning: Never file for divorce as a negotiating tactic or threat. Once filed, you've started an expensive legal process that's difficult to stop. Filing to "scare" your spouse into counseling or negotiation typically escalates conflict dramatically and signals to the court that you're not taking the process seriously.

Key Takeaway: Filing first only helps if you're actually ready. Rushing to the courthouse unprepared is worse than thoughtful response after being served.

Scenario Analysis: When Should You File First?

Let me walk through three real-world scenarios (with details changed to protect confidentiality) that illustrate how this decision plays out:

Scenario 1: The Hidden Asset Situation

Facts: Sarah suspected her husband was hiding business income and had recently transferred cryptocurrency to unknown wallets. They'd been married 18 years, he controlled all finances, and she'd been a stay-at-home parent.

Strategy: We filed immediately, simultaneously issuing preservation letters to every financial institution we could identify and serving written discovery demanding blockchain records. By filing first, we froze assets before he could move more money and secured temporary maintenance to fund her legal expenses.

Outcome: Discovery revealed $340,000 in undisclosed cryptocurrency. Filing first prevented further dissipation.

Scenario 2: The Amicable Separation

Facts: Mark and his wife agreed their 12-year marriage was over. They'd already separated, had similar incomes, and wanted to minimize legal costs. Both wanted to co-parent effectively.

Strategy: We recommended waiting. They negotiated the major terms privately, then one party filed a joint simplified dissolution. Who filed the paperwork was irrelevant—it was purely administrative.

Outcome: Total legal fees under $5,000 combined. Filing first would have introduced unnecessary adversarial dynamics.

Scenario 3: The Relocation Situation

Facts: Jennifer learned her husband was planning to transfer to his company's London office and wanted to take their two children with him. He hadn't yet told her about the transfer.

Strategy: We filed immediately with emergency motions preventing removal of the children from Illinois without court approval. By acting first, we established jurisdiction and prevented what would have been an international custody nightmare.

Outcome: Children remained in Illinois. Father's international transfer became a factor in the parenting plan negotiations.

Key Takeaway: The decision to file first should be based on your specific circumstances—particularly asset protection concerns, relocation risks, or the need for emergency relief.

The Judge Selection Myth

I hear this question constantly: "If I file first, can I pick my judge?"

The short answer is no. In Illinois, case assignment to judges is typically random or based on rotation systems designed specifically to prevent "judge shopping." Cook County uses a randomized assignment system. DuPage, Lake, and other collar counties have similar procedures.

However, filing in a specific county does determine which pool of judges your case draws from. If you have legitimate residence in multiple counties, the decision of where to file can indirectly affect judicial assignment—not because you're selecting a specific judge, but because different counties have different judicial cultures.

What About Substitution of Judge?

Both petitioners and respondents have the right to one substitution of judge as a matter of course under 735 ILCS 5/2-1001. This means you can remove one judge without stating any reason. But this right exists regardless of whether you filed first or responded—it's available to both parties equally.

Pro Tip: Don't waste your substitution of judge right based on internet reputation alone. Consult with an attorney who regularly practices in your county—they know which judges are actually problematic for your type of case versus which ones have undeserved reputations.

Temporary Orders: Where Timing Actually Matters

Calculate Your Maintenance

Use our free Illinois maintenance calculator to estimate your potential support obligations.
Try Calculator

Here's where filing first can provide genuine tactical advantage: temporary orders. These are court orders that govern the parties' conduct during the divorce process—before final judgment is entered.

Temporary Maintenance and Support

If you're the financially dependent spouse, filing first allows you to immediately petition for temporary maintenance. Your petition can include a request for interim support, meaning your spouse must start paying while the divorce proceeds.

If your spouse files first, you can still request temporary maintenance in your response—but you've lost time during which you may have needed that support.

Temporary Custody and Parenting Time

Initial temporary parenting orders often set the baseline that becomes the final arrangement. Judges are reluctant to disrupt established parenting patterns. If you file first with a proposed temporary parenting plan that becomes the status quo, you've influenced the likely outcome.

This is particularly important if you want to establish yourself as the primary residential parent or if you're concerned your spouse might seek to relocate with the children.

Exclusive Possession of the Marital Home

Under 750 ILCS 5/701, courts can award temporary exclusive possession of the marital residence to either spouse. Filing first with a request for exclusive possession—particularly if you can document domestic discord that makes cohabitation problematic—positions you to remain in the home while the divorce proceeds.

Key Takeaway: Temporary orders can significantly impact your divorce trajectory. Filing first lets you frame initial requests and establish the status quo that judges are reluctant to change.

Response Deadlines: What Happens If You Don't File First

If your spouse files before you do, understanding your response timeline is critical:

30-Day Response Window

After being served with a Petition for Dissolution of Marriage, you have 30 days to file an appearance and response. This deadline is firm—missing it can result in default judgment against you.

What Your Response Should Include

Your response isn't just acknowledging receipt of the petition. It should:

Respond to each allegation in the petition (admit, deny, or state insufficient knowledge)
Assert any affirmative defenses
State your own claims for relief (property division, maintenance, custody)
Include any counter-claims

Understanding how divorce filing works in Illinois helps you prepare even if you end up responding rather than initiating.

Emergency Situations

If you're served and face an immediate emergency—your spouse is dissipating assets, threatening to leave the state with children, or engaging in domestic violence—you can file emergency motions immediately. You don't have to wait for the 30-day response period.

Key Takeaway: Being served first isn't a disaster if you respond strategically. Use the 30-day window to prepare thoroughly and file a comprehensive response with your own requests for relief.

protecting digital assets and Filing Strategy

In high-net-worth divorces, digital asset considerations increasingly drive filing strategy. As an attorney with cybersecurity certifications, I've seen how cryptocurrency, digital businesses, and online accounts complicate divorce proceedings.

Cryptocurrency and Blockchain Assets

Unlike bank accounts, cryptocurrency can be moved instantly and anonymously to wallets that are difficult to trace. If you suspect your spouse holds significant cryptocurrency, filing first with immediate preservation demands can prevent transfers that would otherwise be untraceable.

Business Digital Assets

For spouses who own businesses, digital assets often represent significant undisclosed value:

Customer email lists
Proprietary software
Domain names and websites
Social media accounts with monetization value
Digital intellectual property

Filing first allows you to demand forensic preservation of these assets before they can be transferred or destroyed.

Protecting Your Own Digital Security

Before filing—or as soon as you're served—secure your digital life:

Change passwords on all personal accounts
Enable two-factor authentication
Remove spouse's access to shared cloud storage
Secure backup email and phone numbers
Check for tracking software on your devices

Pro Tip: Before serving divorce papers, have a cybersecurity professional sweep your devices for tracking software. I've seen cases where spouses monitored each other's communications throughout the divorce process, compromising legal strategy and settlement negotiations.

Frequently Asked Questions About Filing First in Illinois

Is there an advantage to filing for divorce first?

Yes, but the advantages are tactical rather than legal. Filing first gives you control over timing, allows thorough preparation, triggers automatic restraining orders on your schedule, and lets you frame initial temporary orders requests. However, Illinois courts don't legally favor petitioners over respondents in final judgments—property division, custody, and maintenance decisions are based on statutory factors, not who filed first.

What happens if I file first?

When you file a Petition for Dissolution of Marriage in Illinois, you become the "petitioner" and your spouse becomes the "respondent." You choose the county where the case is filed (assuming proper venue), you control when your spouse is served, automatic restraining orders under 750 ILCS 5/501(a-1) take effect, and if the case goes to trial, you present your evidence first. Your spouse has 30 days after service to file a response.

Does filing first mean I get the house?

No. Filing first has no bearing on which spouse receives the marital residence in the property division. Under 750 ILCS 5/503, courts divide marital property equitably based on factors including each spouse's contribution, economic circumstances, and the children's needs. However, filing first does allow you to immediately request temporary exclusive possession of the home during the divorce process—which can influence the final outcome if you establish residency there.

Can the person who files first pick the judge?

No. Illinois courts use random or rotational assignment systems specifically to prevent judge shopping. However, the petitioner does choose which county to file in (assuming proper venue), which determines the pool of judges available. Both parties retain the right to one substitution of judge as a matter of course under 735 ILCS 5/2-1001, regardless of who filed first.

Does filing first affect custody?

Filing first doesn't directly affect how judges determine custody (now called "allocation of parental responsibilities" in Illinois). Courts make these decisions based on children's best interests under 750 ILCS 5/602.5. However, filing first allows you to propose the initial temporary parenting plan, which can establish a status quo that judges are reluctant to disrupt. The parent who establishes primary physical custody during the divorce process often retains it in the final order.

What is the strategic advantage of being petitioner?

Key strategic advantages include: preparation time to gather documents and secure representation before filing; control over when automatic restraining orders take effect (protecting assets from dissipation); ability to file emergency motions simultaneously with the petition; venue selection in multi-county situations; presenting evidence first at trial; and psychological positioning as the party taking action. These advantages are tactical, not legal preferences in the court's ultimate decisions.

Should I wait for my spouse to file?

Consider waiting if: your divorce will be amicable and contested issues are minimal; you benefit from seeing your spouse's initial characterization of assets and issues; you need more time to prepare financially and emotionally; or you want to avoid being perceived as the party who "broke up the family." Waiting makes sense in collaborative situations but can be dangerous if assets are at risk or you need emergency protective orders.

Does filing first affect property division?

Not directly. Illinois divides marital property equitably under 750 ILCS 5/503 based on statutory factors—neither party receives preference for filing first. However, filing first triggers automatic restraining orders that prevent asset dissipation, allows you to demand immediate financial disclosure, and lets you request temporary orders establishing who pays which bills during the divorce. These process advantages can indirectly affect the final property division by preserving assets and establishing payment patterns.

How long do I have to respond if my spouse files first?

You have 30 days from the date of service to file an appearance and response. This deadline is critical—missing it can result in default judgment. If you need more time, you can request an extension, but courts don't grant these automatically. Use the 30-day window to secure legal representation, gather financial documents, and prepare a comprehensive response that includes your own requests for relief.

Can filing first affect temporary support orders?

Yes—this is one of the most significant practical advantages of filing first. When you file, you can simultaneously petition for temporary maintenance and child support. This means support payments can begin weeks or months earlier than if you wait to respond to your spouse's filing. For financially dependent spouses, filing first ensures you have income to maintain your household and fund legal expenses during the divorce process.

Next Steps: Making Your Decision

The decision to file first should be based on strategic analysis, not emotion or internet advice. Here's how to approach this decision:

Immediate Actions

Gather financial documents—tax returns, bank statements, investment accounts, business records, property deeds—while you have access
Create your divorce preparation checklist and complete it before filing or being served
Consult with an experienced Illinois divorce attorney who can evaluate your specific circumstances
Secure your digital accounts with new passwords and two-factor authentication
Open an individual bank account for personal expenses (not to hide marital assets, but to ensure access to funds)

Questions to Ask Your Attorney

Given my asset protection concerns, should I file immediately?
What emergency relief might I need, and does that require filing first?
Are there venue considerations that favor filing in a particular county?
What's the likely timeline in my county, and how does that affect strategy?
What financial documentation should I secure before filing?

When to Act Immediately

File without delay if:

You have reason to believe your spouse is dissipating assets
There's any history of domestic violence
Your spouse might attempt to relocate with children
You're financially dependent and need immediate support
You've discovered digital forensics services or income

The strategic advantage of filing first isn't about winning a race—it's about positioning yourself for the best possible outcome in your specific situation. Sometimes that means filing immediately. Sometimes it means waiting until you're fully prepared. The key is making an informed decision with proper legal guidance.

If you're considering divorce in Illinois and want to discuss whether filing first makes sense for your situation, contact our office for a strategic consultation. We'll evaluate your circumstances and develop a filing strategy aligned with your goals.