The Real Story About Child Support with 50/50 Custody in Illinois

I have had countless clients walk into my office believing that if they agree to split parenting time equally, child support disappears entirely. It is one of the most common misconceptions in Illinois family law, and it is costing parents—both payers and recipients—thousands of dollars in mistakes.

Let me be direct: 50/50 custody does not automatically eliminate child support in Illinois. Not even close.

How Illinois Actually Calculates Child Support

Since 2017, Illinois uses an "income shares" model under 750 ILCS 5/505. The calculation considers both parents net incomes and the number of children. The state presumes that both parents should contribute to their children expenses in proportion to their income—regardless of how parenting time is divided.

Here is what the law actually looks at:

• Combined net income of both parents
• Number of children
• The basic child support obligation from state guidelines
• Each parent proportional share of that obligation
• The actual parenting time percentage each parent exercises

The Shared Parenting Adjustment Nobody Tells You About

When each parent has the children for at least 146 overnights per year (roughly 40% of the time), Illinois law requires a "shared parenting" calculation. This adjustment accounts for the fact that both households are incurring direct expenses for the children.

But here is the critical part most online articles miss: the higher-earning parent still typically owes support, just at a reduced amount.

I have worked with clients who earned $150,000 while their ex-spouse earned $50,000. With true 50/50 parenting time and two children, my client still owed approximately $800 monthly in child support. Why? Because the children standard of living should not drastically shift between households, and both parents should contribute proportionally to their ability.

The Hidden Costs That Complicate Everything

In real-world divorce cases, the calculation gets even more complex. We are also factoring in:

Health insurance premiums: Who is covering the children? That parent receives a credit.

Childcare expenses: If one parent pays for daycare or after-school care to maintain employment, that cost gets added to the base obligation and split proportionally.

Extracurricular activities: Travel sports, music lessons, tutoring—these are not automatically included but can be negotiated into your agreement.

Private school tuition: If your children attend private school, expect serious negotiations about who pays what percentage.

I have seen parents lose thousands because they did not properly document these expenses or failed to address them in their settlement agreement. One client came to me after her ex stopped contributing to their daughter club soccer team fees—$4,000 annually—because "it was not in the order." We fixed it, but only after unnecessary litigation.

What Courts Actually Consider Beyond the Calculator

Judges have discretion to deviate from guideline calculations when appropriate. In my 15+ years practicing in Cook County and surrounding counties, I have seen deviations based on:

• Significant wealth or assets of either parent
• Children with special needs requiring extraordinary expenses
• Standard of living the children enjoyed before separation
• Educational needs and opportunities
• One parent deliberate unemployment or underemployment

The Myth of Getting Out of Child Support

Let me address this head-on because I hear it constantly: some parents pursue 50/50 custody primarily to avoid child support. This is backward thinking that damages your case and your children.

First, judges see through this strategy immediately. If you have shown minimal interest in parenting during the marriage but suddenly want equal time during divorce proceedings, the court will question your motives. I have watched parents torpedo their credibility—and their legitimate custody arguments—by making it obvious they are focused on money rather than their children best interests.

Second, true 50/50 parenting is demanding. It requires coordination, flexibility, communication with your ex, and a genuine commitment to active parenting. If you are pursuing it as a financial strategy rather than a parenting commitment, you are setting yourself and your children up for failure.

Practical Steps to Protect Your Interests

Whether you are likely to pay or receive child support with shared parenting, here is what you need to do:

Document everything now. Your income, your expenses, your parenting involvement, childcare costs, medical expenses—all of it. The parent with better documentation usually comes out ahead.

Get a realistic calculation early. Do not negotiate blind. Have an attorney run the numbers under different parenting time scenarios so you understand what is actually at stake.

Consider tax implications. Child support is not taxable or deductible, but dependency exemptions, head of household status, and childcare tax credits all matter. Your settlement should address these explicitly.

Build in modification triggers. Income changes, job losses, children aging out—your agreement should specify how these situations will be handled.

Think beyond the minimum. The statutory calculation covers basics. If you want your children to continue music lessons, summer camps, or college savings contributions, negotiate those terms now.

What This Means for Your Case

If you are heading toward a 50/50 custody arrangement, child support will likely still be part of your financial picture. The question is not whether support will be owed, but how much and how it will be structured to work practically for both households.

I have structured agreements where support obligations were offset by one parent covering specific expenses like tuition or healthcare. I have built in step-down provisions as children age and expenses change. I have negotiated lump-sum settlements in place of ongoing monthly payments for clients with complicated income structures.

The key is understanding that Illinois child support law is more nuanced than online calculators suggest. Your specific situation—your incomes, your parenting schedule, your children needs, your family history—requires analysis by someone who has handled hundreds of these cases.

Child support with shared parenting is not about one parent "winning" or "getting out" of obligations. It is about ensuring your children needs are met consistently in both households while both parents contribute fairly. When structured correctly, it removes ongoing conflict and lets you focus on successful co-parenting.

That is the real goal here—not eliminating support, but creating a sustainable financial arrangement that serves your children best interests while protecting your rights.

If you are navigating custody and support questions in Illinois, do not rely on generic information. Contact Steele Family Law for an analysis specific to your situation. We will run the numbers, explain your realistic options, and build a strategy focused on your children wellbeing and your financial security.

Written by Jonathan D. Steele

Chicago divorce attorney with cybersecurity certifications (Security+, CEH, ISC2). Illinois Super Lawyers Rising Star 2016-2025.

Free Consultation

For more insights, read our Divorce Decoded blog.