A screenshot of a text you never sent. A photo that was edited. An audio clip that sounds like your voice saying something you never said. Altering a screenshot has always been easy, and AI tools now make convincing fake photos, video, and audio easy too. This page explains what to do if the other side in your Illinois divorce or custody case offers evidence you believe is fake or altered, how Illinois courts decide whether evidence is genuine, and why you must never alter evidence yourself.
Key points
- The person offering the evidence has to authenticate it. Under Illinois Rule of Evidence 901, a text, screenshot, recording, or photo comes in only if there is evidence sufficient to support a finding that it is what that person claims it is.
- Preserve your originals now. Your own phone, accounts, and backups are often the best proof that a message was changed or never existed.
- Ask for the original, not just the screenshot. Your lawyer can request the native files or devices for inspection and testing and, where justified, bring in a forensic examiner.
- Fabrication has consequences. Illinois courts can impose sanctions and shift attorney's fees, and lying about evidence under oath can be a crime.
- Never edit, crop, or "clean up" evidence yourself. Even a well-meant edit can sink a genuine exhibit and your credibility with it.
What counts as fake or altered evidence in a family case?
Most disputed evidence in divorce and custody cases is ordinary: screenshots of texts, social media posts, emails, photos, and recordings. Problems arise in a few recurring ways:
- Edited screenshots. A contact name changed, a message deleted from the middle of a thread, or a timestamp altered.
- Messages from accounts you do not control. A social media profile or messaging account set up in your name by someone else.
- Selective excerpts. A real message or recording, cut so that the part that changes its meaning is missing.
- AI-generated or AI-altered media. A photo with a face or object swapped in, a video "deepfake," or a cloned voice.
Not every damaging exhibit is fake, and not every incomplete exhibit is a fraud. A cropped thread can often be fixed by putting the rest of the conversation in front of the judge. Illinois Rule of Evidence 106 allows a party, when part of a writing or recorded statement is introduced, to require the introduction at that time of any other part that "ought in fairness to be considered" with it.
How does an Illinois court decide whether a text, photo, or recording is real?
Before any exhibit is considered, the party offering it must authenticate it. Rule 901(a) requires "evidence sufficient to support a finding that the matter in question is what its proponent claims." The rule lists examples of how that can be done, including:
- testimony from a witness with knowledge (for example, the person who received the text);
- "distinctive characteristics," including appearance, contents, and internal patterns, and characteristics "that apply to the source of an electronic communication," considered together with the circumstances;
- identification of a voice by someone who has heard it; and
- evidence describing a process or system and showing that it produces an accurate result.
The judge decides these preliminary questions (Ill. R. Evid. 104(a)). The threshold is not high, which is why the objection has to be specific. Illinois courts do take it seriously. In People v. Kent, 2017 IL App (2d) 140917, the appellate court reversed a conviction because a screenshot of a Facebook post had been admitted without sufficient authentication. The trial court had relied on the profile name, a photo, and the post's content; the appellate court held that was not enough, noting a detective's admission that anyone can set up a profile using an email address.
Originals matter too. Under Illinois Rule of Evidence 1003, a copy is admissible to the same extent as the original unless "a genuine question is raised as to the authenticity of the original" or admitting the copy would be unfair. Raising a genuine question about authenticity is often what gets you access to the phone, account, or native file behind a screenshot.
As of October 2026, Illinois has not adopted a separate evidence rule for AI-generated material; Rule 901 was last amended in 2019, and the general authentication rules apply. The Illinois Supreme Court's policy on artificial intelligence, effective January 1, 2025, states that "deliberately misleading AI-generated content" that "obscures truth-finding and decision-making will not be tolerated."
Did a parent refuse pickup? A hypothetical voicemail comparison
Suppose one parent says the other refused to pick up their daughter at six. What would you want to hear before drawing that conclusion? The following fictional example was created for this article. The quoted words, times, and records are invented.
Scroll horizontally to read all columns.
| Record | What it shows | What remains open |
|---|---|---|
| 12-second forwarded excerpt | A clip forwarded at 5:05 p.m. includes the words “I can’t pick her up at six.” | The listener hears an apparent refusal. The forwarding time says when the clip was shared. Who made the excerpt, and what came immediately before those words? |
| 47-second full voicemail | The recipient’s saved voicemail begins, “I’m waiting for the five o’clock train. If it’s canceled, I can’t pick her up at six.” Later the caller adds, “I’ll call you from the platform when I know.” | The train cancellation was a condition. Listening to the full message changes the meaning of the excerpt. Who recognizes the voice, and did the promised follow-up happen? |
| Phone call log | The recipient’s phone lists a missed call at 4:10 p.m. from the number saved for the other parent. The voicemail screen also shows 4:10 p.m. | The matching times help connect the records. The log alone cannot identify who spoke, supply the words, or establish who ultimately picked up the child. |
For a discussion with counsel, keep the forwarded file and the full voicemail as separate records. Note whose phone holds each item, who received it, and whether that person can identify the voice. In this example the missing condition explains the apparent refusal. The difference between versions, by itself, does not establish that anyone generated a synthetic voice.
What should I do first if I think an exhibit is fake?
- Tell your lawyer right away and be specific. Identify exactly what is wrong: a message you never sent, a time that does not match, a name that is not how the contact appears on your phone, a detail in a photo that could not be accurate.
- Preserve your own evidence. Keep the phone. Do not delete threads, factory-reset a device, or let disappearing-message or auto-delete settings run. Keep cloud backups. The Illinois Supreme Court has recognized that a potential litigant owes "a duty to take reasonable measures to preserve the integrity of relevant and material evidence" (Shimanovsky v. General Motors Corp., 181 Ill. 2d 112 (1998)), and that duty applies to you as much as to the other side.
- Write down what you remember about when and how the real conversation, call, or event happened, and who else was present or received the same messages.
- Do not respond in kind. Do not post about it, accuse the other parent in front of the children, or try to access the other person's phone or accounts to "prove" it. Getting evidence the wrong way creates new problems. See Illinois recording law in divorce before you record anyone.
How can my lawyer test whether evidence was faked?
Illinois discovery rules reach electronic evidence. "Documents" include photographs, recordings, communications, and electronically stored information (Ill. S. Ct. R. 201(b)(1), (b)(4)). Under Rule 214, a party can request that the other side produce documents, including electronically stored information, for "inspection, copying, reproduction photographing, testing or sampling," and electronic material must be produced in the form in which it is ordinarily maintained or in a reasonably usable form. In practice, that can mean asking for:
- the original image, audio, or video file rather than a screenshot or forwarded copy;
- the complete thread or account export, not just the selected messages;
- an inspection or forensic copy of the device, often under a protective order that limits or conditions the examination (Ill. S. Ct. R. 201(c)); and
- records from third parties, such as phone carriers or platforms, through subpoenas, within the limits those companies and federal privacy law impose.
A qualified digital forensic examiner can compare a file against device logs, account records, and metadata, and look for signs of editing or generation. Expert testimony is governed by Illinois Rule of Evidence 702, and Illinois follows the Frye standard: when an expert's opinion rests on a "new or novel" scientific method, the party offering it must show the method has gained general acceptance in its field. Some AI-detection tools are new, so the method matters as much as the conclusion.
Timing matters as well. If your lawyer retains an examiner as a consultant who will not testify, Rule 201(b)(3) generally protects the consultant's identity and opinions from discovery absent exceptional circumstances. That is one reason to involve your lawyer before hiring anyone.
What happens to someone who offers fake evidence?
Illinois law gives the court several tools:
- Illinois Supreme Court Rule 137. Signing a petition, motion, or other court paper certifies that it is "well grounded in fact" after reasonable inquiry. A filing built on fabricated evidence can lead to sanctions, including an order to pay the other side's reasonable expenses and attorney's fees.
- Rule 219(c). When a party unreasonably fails to comply with discovery rules or orders, the court can bar that party from pursuing a claim or calling a witness on the issue, strike pleadings, enter a default, and order payment of the other side's reasonable expenses and attorney's fees, plus a monetary penalty when the misconduct is willful.
- 750 ILCS 5/508(b). If a hearing was "precipitated or conducted for any improper purpose," the court "shall allocate fees and costs of all parties for the hearing" to the party or lawyer who acted improperly. See attorney's fees for bad-faith litigation under section 508(b).
- Credibility and custody. A judge who finds that a parent manufactured evidence can weigh that finding when deciding whom to believe. In allocating decision-making and parenting time, Illinois courts may consider "any other factor that the court expressly finds to be relevant" (750 ILCS 5/602.5(c)(15); 5/602.7(b)(17)).
- Criminal exposure. A knowingly false, material statement under oath can be perjury (720 ILCS 5/32-2), and a knowingly false material statement in a document certified under 735 ILCS 5/1-109 is a Class 3 felony. Whether to charge is a prosecutor's decision, not the family court's.
Could I be accused of faking evidence?
Yes, and the best protection is how you handle your own evidence from the start:
- Give your lawyer complete, unedited originals: the full thread, the original photo file, the whole recording.
- Do not crop, annotate, blur, or "enhance" an exhibit, and do not run photos or audio through AI editing or cleanup tools. If something needs to be redacted, your lawyer will handle it. Illinois Supreme Court Rule 138, for example, limits Social Security, driver's license, and financial account numbers in court filings.
- Keep the device the evidence came from, and do not change settings that affect what it stores.
- Be ready to explain how you got each item and when.
An altered exhibit, even one changed for an innocent reason, invites the same authenticity challenge you would raise against the other side and can damage your credibility on every other issue in the case.
When should I talk to a lawyer?
As soon as you learn the other side intends to use something you believe is fake, and before any hearing. Emergency hearings on orders of protection and parenting time can move quickly, and objections, preservation demands, and requests for originals are most effective when made early. Talk to a lawyer before you hire a forensic examiner, before you respond to the other parent about the evidence, and before you delete or change anything on your own devices. For more on how electronic evidence is collected and tested, see digital evidence in an Illinois divorce.
About this article
Jonathan D. Steele, a partner at Beermann LLP, presented "Deepfake Evidence in Family Court: Detection and Sanctions," a continuing legal education program for lawyers offered by myLawCLE and co-sponsored by the Federal Bar Association, on July 28, 2026. This article adapts that program for people going through a divorce or custody case. His other programs are listed on the speaking page. To discuss a case, call (312) 621-4394 or use the contact form.
Sources
- Illinois Rules of Evidence 104, 106, 702, 901, and 1003: illinoiscourts.gov
- Illinois Supreme Court Rules 137, 138, 201, 214, and 219: illinoiscourts.gov
- Illinois Supreme Court Policy on Artificial Intelligence (eff. Jan. 1, 2025): illinoiscourts.gov
- 750 ILCS 5/508: ilga.gov; 750 ILCS 5/602.5: ilga.gov; 750 ILCS 5/602.7: ilga.gov
- 720 ILCS 5/32-2: ilga.gov; 735 ILCS 5/1-109: ilga.gov
- People v. Kent, 2017 IL App (2d) 140917: opinion
- Shimanovsky v. General Motors Corp., 181 Ill. 2d 112 (1998): opinion
This article explains general Illinois law as of October 2026. It is not legal advice about your situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Going through a divorce? Get the checklist judges wish you had.
Download the free Illinois Divorce Preparation Checklist - the 30 things to do before your first court date. Plus weekly insights from a Chicago family law attorney.
For more insights, read our Divorce Decoded blog.